parking_solution/wiki/log.md

# Wiki Log

Append-only chronological record. Each entry: `## [YYYY-MM-DD] <op> | <subject>`.
Query with `grep "^## \[" log.md | tail -5`.

## [2026-06-14] ingest | Parking System — Architecture & Design Notes
First source ingested. Bootstrapped wiki scaffolding (CLAUDE.md schema, index.md,
overview.md, log.md). Created source summary, 14 entity pages, 9 concept pages, and
decision records (settled decisions + 6 open questions). Source is a dense design
doc covering stack, threat model, device architecture, UHPPOTE access control, the
custom ESP32 controller alternative, readers, and a reference BOM.

## [2026-06-15] decision | JWT key choice + ESP32 deferred
From app work, not a new source. Added [[open-questions]] #7 (symmetric vs.
asymmetric JWT signing key — raised by the commit security review; prefer RS256/EdDSA
so verifying hosts hold only a public key, mirroring the ATECC608 / challenge-response
property). Marked [[esp32-custom-controller]] `status: deferred` per decision not to
implement device-level auth for now (access control stays on UHPPOTE + network
isolation); noted in [[open-questions]] #6. Updated [[local-jwt-auth]] (hardened secret
handling + 8h expiry, asymmetric-key pointer) and the index.

## [2026-06-15] decision | Device-agnostic registry + first-run setup
From app work. Made the [[device-adapter-pattern]] selectable: added a
[[device-registry]] (catalog of drivers per category) and a [[first-run-setup]]
flow so the admin picks a device per lane at install. Categories: access
(ZKTeco / ESP32 relay), reader (Wiegand / TCP-IP), camera (Hikvision / Dahua,
snapshot-on-event), printer. Added a `CameraDevice` interface; new `lane_devices`
+ `setup_state` tables (migration 0001); admin-only setup endpoints. Stub drivers
for now (no real vendor protocols yet). Verified catalog + assign + validation +
auth end to end.

## [2026-06-15] decision | UHPPOTE library chosen + real driver
Researched Node options for the UHPPOTE controller. Chose the official
**`uhppoted`** npm package (MIT, actively maintained, full API incl. openDoor,
get-event(s)/event-index, set-listener, restore-default — covers the whole
[[event-log-ingestion]] design). Rejected: raw-dgram DIY (reinvents the lib),
node-red-contrib-uhppoted (wrong model), Go REST sidecar (extra runtime). Added
it to @parking/devices and implemented a real `uhppote` [[uhppote-controller]]
access driver (pulseOpen→openDoor, healthCheck→getStatus), registered in the
catalog. CJS interop: default-import + destructure. Verified it builds, appears
in the catalog, and degrades to "offline" gracefully without hardware. Real
on-VLAN test still pending.

## [2026-06-15] feature | Device discovery (UHPPOTE scan in setup)
The frontend had no way to find a UHPPOTE — but the controllers self-announce via
UDP broadcast. Added a generic [[device-discovery]] capability: optional
`DiscoverableDriver.discover()` on the registry, implemented by the `uhppote`
driver via `getDevices`. New admin-only `GET /api/setup/discover/:driverId`
(health-checks each found device); catalog now returns a `discoverable` list.
SetupWizard gains a "Scan for controllers" button that lists found devices with
health badges and auto-fills serial + host on selection. Verified: catalog flags
uhppote; discover runs and fails gracefully without hardware (broadcast EACCES);
non-discoverable driver → 400; no token → 401. Modeled generically so cameras
(ONVIF) can add discovery later.

## [2026-06-15] test+blocker | UHPPOTE hardware bring-up + entry-flow blocker
Brought up the real UHPPOTE (serial 225088491, fw 09120) end to end. Fixed the
networking path: WSL2 mirrored mode, then driver bugs — subnet-directed broadcast
(the lib doesn't enable SO_BROADCAST for global 255.255.255.255), broadcast must
match the target's subnet for unicast reply routing (health-check timeout fix),
multi-subnet discovery, and serialized I/O (concurrent calls collided on :60001).
Added .env loading (Node --env-file), env-gated+fail-closed SETUP_AUTH_BYPASS, and
an authBypass flag so the wizard drops the token field. Test scripts in
apps/server/scripts/ (uhppote-listen, uhppote-relay).

VERIFIED on hardware: discovery; host-commanded openDoor doors 1&2 (physical +
reason="remote open door"); button presses live (reason="push button ok").

BLOCKER FOUND: the controller push-button input auto-opens the relay in firmware —
no command to report-without-opening — so ticket-first entry (button→print→open)
is impossible as wired. UHPPOTE can't do it on that input; ZKTeco *might* via a
programmable aux input + PULL SDK but that's unverified and needs a new driver.
Recorded in [[access-controller-button-flow]] + [[zkteco-controller]]. Entry-lane
hardware decision paused to focus on the business side.

## [2026-06-15] feature | Cookie-based auth/authz (login, CSRF)
Built real authentication: bcrypt login → JWT in an HttpOnly+SameSite=Strict
cookie, readable CSRF cookie + X-CSRF-Token header (double-submit) on mutations,
role-guarded routes. Routes: /api/auth/{login,logout,me}. First admin seeded via
`pnpm --filter @parking/server seed-admin`. Removed the SETUP_AUTH_BYPASS shim
and the wizard token field; the SPA gates on /api/auth/me and only shows setup to
admins. Same-origin via the Vite dev proxy and a new prod nginx config
(deploy/nginx.conf). Verified end to end (curl + browser): wrong pass→401,
login→cookies set, me→admin, assign without CSRF→403 / with→201, no cookie→401,
session persists across reload. Updated [[local-jwt-auth]].

## [2026-06-15] lint+docs | Dev-environment pages (WSL networking, workflow)
Captured hard-won dev knowledge that was only in commit messages: new
[[wsl-dev-networking]] (WSL2 NAT blocks UDP broadcast → mirrored mode + the
multi-interface / subnet-broadcast / IPv6-localhost gotchas that remained) and
[[local-dev-workflow]] (setup, seed:admin, the dev-server-hang from the broken
strip-types script → tsx, the 127.0.0.1 proxy fix, .env loading). Corrected the
earlier "broadcast permission (EACCES)" note in [[device-discovery]] — the real
cause was the lib not enabling SO_BROADCAST for the global 255.255.255.255;
documented the three verified broadcast gotchas + serialization. Added a `reference`
page type to the schema; new "Dev environment" index section.

## [2026-06-15] decision | Dingtian relay chosen; HTTP over MQTT; unmanned direction
New relay+input controller on hand (Dingtian 4ch). Its inputs are decoupled from
relays (configurable via input_link_relay) — solves the [[access-controller-button-flow]]
blocker the UHPPOTE couldn't. Transport decision [[dingtian-vs-mqtt]]: direct
HTTP/UDP now (UDP string for relay control on :60001; device input_link_url HTTP
push for button events), MQTT skipped (broker = infra + failure mode + overkill at
this scale) but kept for later multi-lane scale. Recorded the stated roadmap to
**fully unmanned, no-booth** operation in [[autonomous-direction]] and its threat-model
shift (operator-fraud → unattended-machine threats). New stub [[dingtian-relay]]
with the full protocol from the SDK. Driver + on-hardware test still to build.

## [2026-06-15] driver+test | Dingtian driver built; button blocker RESOLVED
Built the `dingtian` access driver (AccessControlDevice relay control + InputDevice
poll-based button events + new PreconditionDevice capability). Verified end to end on
real hardware (DT-R004 @ 10.0.10.172, HTTP config on :8080, UDP control :60001):
status read, relay pulse, input press/release. Disabled `input_link_relay` via the
driver's fixPreconditions (GET config → flag 0 + clear maps → POST config_set), then
confirmed: pressing inputs now fires NO relay (0000 status) — host-in-the-loop entry
works. The [[access-controller-button-flow]] blocker is RESOLVED. Gotcha recorded in
[[dingtian-relay]]: config_set requires injecting "command":"setconfig" after "status"
(GET omits it) or the write silently no-ops. Added httpPort config field (port 8080 ≠
default 80). Test script apps/server/scripts/dingtian-test.mjs. Next: input HTTP-push
endpoint + wiring input→ticket→pulseOpen.

## [2026-06-15] cleanup | Remove UHPPOTE/ZKTeco code; wiki → rejected/historical
Neither UHPPOTE nor ZKTeco is used (Dingtian chosen). Removed their code:
deleted access-uhppote.ts, uhppoted.d.ts, access.ts (zkteco/esp32 stubs), the
three uhppote-*.mjs scripts; dropped the `uhppoted` npm dep from both packages;
unregistered uhppote/zkteco/esp32-relay from the driver registry; updated example
comments. Catalog access drivers now = dingtian only. Build green.
Wiki: kept the pages but marked [[uhppote-controller]] + [[zkteco-controller]]
rejected/historical, [[uhppote-vs-esp32]] historical; re-pointed all "current
device" framing (standing-decisions, bom, overview, open-questions) to
[[dingtian-relay]]; noted no current driver uses [[device-discovery]]. Transferable
concepts (network-isolation, event-log-ingestion, barrier-not-a-door, threat-model)
kept as-is. Links lint clean; raw source untouched (immutable).

## [2026-06-15] feature | Dingtian input HTTP-push → backend (no polling)
Wired the device's "Input Link URL" feature so it HTTP-pushes button events to
our backend — no polling. Driver `configureInputPush()` writes input_link_url
(per-input server/port/path, en=1, active-LOW, plain HTTP) via the config API
(reusing the #writeConfig + command:setconfig helper). New backend route
`routes/devices.ts`: public `GET/POST /api/devices/dingtian/:deviceId/input/:n/{on,off}`
→ emits onto an internal device-events bus (device-events.ts, EventEmitter) for
the entry flow to consume. VERIFIED on hardware: configured device, real presses
on all 4 inputs pushed to the backend (input N on+off, source = device IP). Trust
model recorded in [[device-input-flow]]: flat network / no VLAN → backend is source
of truth, every open is a signed event (out-of-band open = anomaly); push endpoint
not behind cookie auth (machine call), shared-secret available as defence-in-depth.
Next: wire signed event + ticket print + pulseOpen.

## [2026-06-15] feature | Dingtian push auth via HTTP Digest (hardware-tested)
Secured the device→backend input push. Empirically tested auth options on the
device: HTTPS-to-self-signed FAILS, Basic works, **Digest works** → chose Digest
(MD5, qop=auth): password never on the wire, single-use nonces. Backend
digest-auth.ts (challenge/verify) + source-IP allowlist on the push route;
per-device pushUser/pushPassword generated on assign, written to the device and
stored in lane_devices (admin never types a URL/secret). Driver
configureInputPush now sets auth=2 + creds; the assign flow auto-configures the
device and persists the creds (net.ts derives the backend IP on the device's
subnet). Removed the earlier URL-token approach (token in URL is sniffable/logged).
TWO HARD-WON DEVICE BUGS fixed: (1) config_set requires an explicit Content-Length
— the device silently ignores chunked bodies (Node's default), which masqueraded
as "writes don't apply" all session; (2) the `pass` field caps at 31 chars →
use a 24-char password. Driver #writeConfig now polls-until-verified (device
reboots on apply). VERIFIED on hardware: assign auto-configures the device, then
all 4 inputs push with Digest auth, zero failures. Recorded in [[device-input-flow]].

## [2026-06-15] feature | Setup wizard: Test connection + Save & configure
Two-step device setup UX. New admin-only POST /api/setup/test (healthCheck +
checkPreconditions, no save / no device change). The assign (Save) step now also
fixes preconditions (disables input_link_relay) before configuring push — closing
a gap where assigned devices could still auto-fire relays; fails the save with no
DB row if device config fails (no orphan rows). SetupWizard wires the config
fields → Test button (health badge + precondition warnings) → Save & configure
button. Verified in-browser against the real device: Test shows ● ready +
preconditions OK; Save persists the row AND writes the device's Input Link URL
(push path matches the saved device id). Admin never logs into the device web UI.
Updated [[first-run-setup]].

## [2026-06-15] feature | Device hardening: binary relay + relay_pw + disable channels
Hardened the Dingtian relay control for the flat (no-VLAN) network. Switched
pulseOpen from the unauthenticated string protocol (:60001) to the **binary
protocol (:60000) with a relay password** — the only authenticated relay option
(frame verified on hardware: FF AA <sess> 03 <pwLE> <relayByte> <jogLE>). New
HardenableDevice capability: harden() sets a random relay_pw + disables unused
channels (rs485/can/tcp×2/mqtt → p:255, keep UDP binary+string). Folded into the
assign/Save flow (preconditions → harden → push); relayPassword stored in
lane_devices. Verified end to end: assign configures + hardens the device, config
API stays reachable, pulseOpen with the stored password fires the relay, without
it is rejected.

⚠️ LESSON: enabling the device's HTTP CGI session check (session_en) on this
firmware breaks the config-READ API (ECONNRESET) — locked us out, needed a FACTORY
RESET to recover. harden() deliberately does NOT touch session_en. The open CGI
API is accepted as flat-network reality; the signed log is the real guarantee.
Recorded in [[device-input-flow]] + [[dingtian-relay]].

## [2026-06-14] query | Dingtian web-login rotation + CGI API is unauthenticated
While addressing "change the device's default admin/admin", traced the device web
UI JS (system.js) → the change-login endpoint is
`GET /userset.cgi?<old_u>&<old_p>&<new_u>&<new_p>&` (response `&0&/&` = success,
`&2&/&` = wrong old pw). Added a best-effort `setWebLogin`/`#rotateWebLogin` step
to `harden()` (new pw stored back as config `webPassword`, stripped from API
responses). KEY FINDING: the device CGI API needs NO authentication — config dump,
config write, relay fire, and userset.cgi itself all return 200 unauthenticated
(verified on 10.0.10.5). admin/admin gates only the browser UI; there is no
inbound-auth setting (only session_en, which bricks the read API). So rotating the
login is COSMETIC, not a boundary — the signed event log remains the real
guarantee. Recorded in [[dingtian-relay]] (new Hardening section).

## [2026-06-14] ingest | Rongta 80mm printer driver + printer roles/failover
- Added `rongta` PrinterDevice driver (ESC/POS over raw TCP 9100); registered in registry.
- Decision: ≥2 printers per lane by role (entry-dispenser outside, booth-receipt inside);
  entry ticket fails over outside→booth (asymmetric — receipts never print outside).
- Selection logic lives in packages/devices/printer-routing.ts (orderForRole, printWithFailover).
- One unit verified reachable at 10.0.10.6:9100 from host (TCP connect OK).
- New pages: [[rongta-printer]], [[printer-roles-failover]]. Updated [[bom]], [[index]].
- Open: all-printers-down policy belongs to the (not-yet-built) entry flow, not the printer layer.

## [2026-06-14] ingest | Live printer status monitoring
- Added MonitorableDevice.readStatus()/PrinterStatus capability in packages/devices.
- Rongta readStatus() scrapes the device's own /prn_stat.htm (Cover/Cutter/Paper End/Near End/
  Off-Line) — chosen over hand-decoding DLE EOT because this clone's DLE EOT bytes don't match
  the canonical ESC/POS bit layout (verified on hardware; risk of false-healthy).
- Server PrinterMonitor: polls enabled monitorable printers (PRINTER_POLL_MS, default 5s),
  caches latest, emits "printer-status" on change. API: GET /api/printers/status + SSE stream.
- Verified live: 10.0.10.6 -> ready (all flags clear); unreachable host -> offline (no throw);
  bus emits on change, suppresses unchanged. Full repo typechecks (8/8).
- New page: [[printer-status-monitoring]]. Updated [[rongta-printer]], [[index]].
- Open: capture the page's actual text for an ACTIVE fault (pull paper / open cover) to confirm
  the Yes flip; wire degraded/offline into failover + entry-flow all-down policy.

## [2026-06-15] ingest | Multi-instance device setup (add/remove per category)
- Confirmed the data model was already multi-instance (lane_devices = one row per instance,
  assign always inserts); the limitation was UI-only (one slot per category).
- Backend: added DELETE /api/setup/assign/:id (unassign); /state now redacts secrets
  (pushPassword/webPassword/relayPassword) via a shared redactSecrets() also used by /assign.
- Web: SetupWizard reworked — each category lists assigned instances (with Remove) + "Add
  another" form; select-type config fields now render as dropdowns (fixes printer role input).
- Verified via Fastify inject: 2 printers assigned to one lane -> both listed, no secret leak,
  delete -> 204, delete unknown -> 404, count drops to 1. Full repo typechecks (8/8).
- Updated [[first-run-setup]].

## [2026-06-15] ingest | Append-only signed event log (Dingtian input pushes persist)
- Q: does the Dingtian push events? -> inputs YES (input_link_url), relay opens NO (device keeps
  no log). Host is the source of truth; a relay open w/o matching signed event is the anomaly.
- Implemented EventLog (apps/server/event-log.ts): serialized append, monotonic index, prevHash
  chain, signature; verifyChain() detects tamper/reorder/delete. Read: GET /api/events;
  integrity: GET /api/events/verify (admin).
- Signer abstraction (packages/shared) over the ATECC608; SoftwareSigner (HMAC, EVENT_SIGNING_KEY)
  shipped now since chip wiring is open-question #6. Caveat documented: software signer is
  tamper-evident but NOT unforgeable-by-owner.
- Wired bus -> log: Dingtian input pushes become input_received events (lane mapping TODO).
- Added ParkingEventType 'input_received'.
- Verified via inject: push w/o digest -> 401; pushes -> 2 signed+chained events; verify -> ok;
  direct DB tamper -> verifyChain catches at the right index; deleted row -> index gap. 5 concurrent
  appends -> indices 1..5 intact. Full repo typechecks.
- Updated [[append-only-event-chain]], [[dingtian-relay]].

## [2026-06-15] ingest | Event log + Dingtian string-protocol security fix
- Append-only signed event log shipped (EventLog, Signer abstraction over ATECC608 w/ SoftwareSigner
  HMAC; GET /api/events + /api/events/verify). Dingtian input pushes persist as input_received.
  Verified on hardware: shorting I1-I4 -> 8 signed+chained events, verifyChain ok.
- SECURITY (verified on hardware): the password-less string protocol (udp2) can fire relays
  ("11" -> relay1 on) with NO auth, bypassing relay_pw. Fixes: status reads moved to authenticated
  binary read (cmd 0x00); harden() disables udp2 BEST-EFFORT (firmware V3.6J config API refuses,
  but web UI works) and returns a warning instead of throwing. After web-UI disable, the "11" attack
  is dead and binary control/status still work.
- GAP (user-identified): event log captures host-originated actions only; out-of-band relay
  actuation (sniffed relay_pw, string protocol, ip_watchdog) produces NO event — proven on hardware.
  Real control is reconciliation vs. an independent witness; witness+reconciliation NOT yet built.
- Device web login (webUser/webPassword) now un-redacted in setup state (admin-only device area);
  pushPassword/relayPassword stay machine-only.
- harden() warnings surfaced via the assign response.
- localAddress threaded through the Dingtian driver (device-facing-IP foundation; multi-homed hosts).
- INCIDENT: probing default.cgi factory-reset the bench device (now at 192.168.1.100, defaults).
  Re-provisioning is the ADMIN's job via First-run setup (app must not hardcode site IPs).
- Updated [[append-only-event-chain]], [[dingtian-relay]].